www.ThucBishops.com


 

Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam

 
 

DOWNLOAD the CMRI 2011 Conference Files:
Lecture: "The Society of St. Pius V and the Thuc Bishops"

Video of Entire Presentation (2:03:58 - YouTube)

Part 1 Audio File (1:01:10 - 21.0 MB)
Part 2 Audio File (27:51 - 9.6 MB)
Part 3 Audio File (25:30 - 8.8 MB)
Part 4 Audio File (6:07 - 2.1 MB)

PowerPoint Presentation "SSPV & Thuc Bishops" (31 slides - PDF)
Printable PowerPoint Presentation (same as above, print-friendly)

Get it in Print!

Order a Paperback Copy of the Study HERE

 

 
 

An Open Letter to

Bishop Clarence Kelly

on the "Thuc Bishops"

and the Errors in

The Sacred and the Profane

 

 

by

Mario Derksen, M.A.

 

Another Good Read:

The Answers
by Fr. Kevin Vaillancourt

A Collection of Arguments for and against the Thuc Consecrations

Available
on YouTube:

Fr. Cekada-Fr. Jenkins Debate on SSPV Policy of Refusing the Sacraments to Thuc Line Adherents (2002)

The Other Side:

Link to Bp. Kelly's Book The Sacred and the Profane in PDF

See for yourself which side has the evidence in its favor

Available
on YouTube:

Video of 1991 Debate between CMRI and SSPV Clergy in Cincinnati, Ohio

   
   
   
     
 

A Study of Catholic Principles
Applicable to the Fact, Validity, and Lawfulness
of the 1981 Episcopal Consecrations of Bishop Ngo-Dinh-Thuc

 
     
  Download the Open Letter here:  
  Full Version in PDF (101 pages; 4.0 MB)  
     
  Don't have time to read all 101 pages?
Download the Summary:
 
  Excerpt: Summary of Major Points in PDF (5 pages; 156 KB)  
     
     
 

Contents:

 
 
Introduction  
Part I - The Fact of Bp. Thuc's 1981 Episcopal Consecrations
Part II - The Validity of these Consecrations
Part III - The Lawfulness of these Consecrations
Appendix A - Is Rejecting the Thuc Consecrations just "Following the Safer Course"?
Appendix B - Did Bp. Thuc Simulate a Sacrament?
Appendix C - Bp. Thuc's Intervention Regarding Non-Christians at Vatican II
Appendix D - Was Bp. Thuc Guilty of Heresy?
Appendix E - Did Bp. Thuc Change the Rite of Episcopal Consecration?
Appendix F - Is the Episcopal Lineage of Bp. Thuc "Sordid"?
Appendix G - Photographs of the 1981 Thuc Consecrations
Appendix H - The Consecration Certificate of Bp. Carmona
Appendix I - Short Bibliography
 
     
     
 

Comments? Feedback?
E-Mail the Author:

 

 
 

(Please refrain from commenting on the study without having read it in its entirety.)

 

 
 

Due to a lack of serious objections to the study as of August 3, 2013, there is currently no plan for publishing objections and replies.